The Best Puppy Toys for 2026

The Best Puppy Toys for 2026!

New year, new pup? Starting out with your first dog? Scrambling for ways to keep up with their needs and unfaltering energy? We've got you covered! You can rest assured that the Real Pet Store has an abundance of dog toys to keep your furry friend entertained. But it can often be best to get supplies such as food and toys that are specifically designed for puppies, as they can be much safer and appropriate - and therefore more easily enjoyed! 

Today, we look at the best puppy toys for 2026. 

We calculate the list based on a simple formula of volume of sales divided by total number of complaints, warranty faults and returns during 2025. The highest-scoring top 5 are listed below. 

1. All For Paws Little Buddy - One of the most popular puppy toys that has landed in dog owners' shopping carts is the All For Paws Little Buddy Heart Beat toy. Choose from a sweet little bunny, bear, sheep or bone-shaped pillow, all of which are incredibly soft and the perfect size for cuddling and carrying around. With a built-in heart beat simulator, replicating the vibrations and sound of their mother's heartbeat, and a warm bag that can be heated up up in the microwave, these adorable toys are the perfect companion to ease separation anxiety and provide reassurance and comfort. 

2. Coachi Tuggi Helix -  For the more active moments in your pup's life, the Coachi Tuggi Helix is a great choice for both training and fun and games! Lightweight yet incredibly strong, this toy is perfect for tough-tuggers and interactive play. Have fun together whilst training - use the Tuggi Helix as an exciting reward, and see how it helps redirect puppy mouthing and biting, and encourages recall, all whilst creating engaging play! Available in various designs, including a foam ball and spider design. Shop Coachi Tuggi products here. 

3. LickiMat Yoggie Pot - Put some fun into dinnertime with the LickiMat Yoggie Pot - a slow-feeder bowl that doubles up as enriching play for your dog. Compatible with kibble, wet foods, treat pastes and freezer safe foods, this bowl encourages licking and releases endorphins. A great interactive feeder that will get your pup excited for each mealtime! Suitable for dogs of all sizes and breeds, and available in multiple colours. 

4. JW Puppy Connects Soft-ee Set - This set is a staple for any puppy owner looking to help their furry friend with their chewing instincts and teething. Whilst primarily nurturing your puppy's playtime, this set of toys is designed with multiple sensory features, both for engagement and to aid teething, gently massaging your puppy's gums as they chew and play.  

5. My Dog Luxury Plush Dog Toys - Another fantastic range of toys that act as a comforting companion for your pup as they navigate separation anxiety and stressful situations. With a stuffable tummy, you can put scented items that are of particular comfort inside, whilst the built in crinkle paper encourages snuggling and cuddling. Available in six different characters, including a bear, elephant, and lion, to suit your dog's personality. Shop here! 

Image: My Dog Luxury Plush Dog Toy Bear

There are so many ways to encourage, comfort and engage your puppy as they grow up in a busy, exciting and, at times, overwhelming world. Toys specifically aimed at puppies are a great way to provide that reassurance and bond with your dog in ways that suit them best.

Above are listed the top 5 best puppy toys for 2026, based on Real Pet Store's 2025 sales and reliability data from Real Pet Store outlets on eBay, Amazon and official website. 

To shop for puppy toys, please click here.